Ahead of the big day tomorrow, the spookiest day of the entire spooky season, we grilled the team on their favorite candy. But not just any candy, their favorite candy to nab while trick-or-treating on Halloween. It’s an important distinction because while some candy is good throughout the rest of the year, it doesn’t hit the mark on Halloween.

October 31st is the Super Bowl of candy eating, it’s the Catalina Wine Mixer. For example, if you’re just perusing the aisles of CVS for some candy to sneak into the movie theater with you on, say, March 19th or August 2nd, yeah sure, grab those Mentos or those Peach Rings, or even some Lifesavers. But if you knocked on a door on Halloween and said Trick-or-Treat and got any of those tossed into your bag, that house would be vandalized with the quickness.

The results of our poll were mixed, like any Trick-or-Treat bag.

Bobby Hundreds, co-founder:

1. Krackle bar
2. Peanut M&Ms
3. Pink or red Starburst

Ben Hundreds, co-founder:

1. Reese’s Pieces
2. Reese’s Cups
3. More Reese’s

Josh, sales:

1. Haribo gummies
2. Reese’s cups
3. Snickers

Awad, digital marketing:

1. Whoppers
2. Reese’s cups
3. Crunch bars

Sandy, social and digital:

1. Sour Punch Straws (the small individual packs somehow taste better than the regular pack ALWAYS, never sweaty)
2. Reese’s cups
3. Double Bubble Gum

Baeth, photo:

1. Take 5
2. Snickers Ice Cream Bar
3. Sno-Caps (don’t @ me)

Brice, marketing:

1. Reese’s cups
2. Butterfinger
3. Almond Joy

Charlie, digital marketing:

1. Reese’s cups
2. King Size Twix
3. King Size Starbursts

Lindsey, Unidentified Agency:

1. Reese’s cups
2. Swedish Fish
3. Grape Laffy Taffy

Allison, photo:

1. Grape Laffy Taffy
2. Peanut Butter M&Ms
3. Tootsie Rolls

Erica, design:

1. Reese’s cups
2. Kit Kat
3. Almond Joy

Justin, marketing:

1. Peanut M&Ms
2. Gummy Cheeseburgers
3. Kit Kat

Duke, content:

1. Fun Size Reese’s cups
2. Peanut M&Ms
3. Purple bag Skittles

David, graphics:

1. Crunch bar
2. Trolli Sour Bite Crawlers
3. Twix

Heavy, special projects:

1. Hershey’s Cookies and Cream bar
2. Andes Mints
3. Trolli Sour Bite Crawlers

Lynders, The Hundreds UK:

1. Crunchie Bar Treat Size – that sweet honeycomb centre
2. Freddo Bar – Pure Cadbury chocolate goodness in the shape of a cartoon frog!
3. Kinder Surprise Halloween Special